Why yes, this is an attempt to ban books

Down the road from me in a Houston suburb, a minister has petitioned the city council to purge 75 fantasy books from the public library.

Pastor Wants ‘Demonic’ Books Removed from Public Library

Pastor Phillip Missick of King of Saints Tabernacle, a Messianic church, filed a complaint with Austin Memorial Library, Cleveland’s public library, asking that many fiction books on vampires, demons and the supernatural be purged. He says he was stunned to find the young adult section full of books like “Blood Promise,” “Twilight,” and the “Vampire Knight” series.

“This is dark. There’s a sexual element. You have creatures that aren’t human. I think it’s dangerous for our kids,” said Missick.

This wearies me. I hope I don’t need to explain why I think this is wrongheaded, fearful, oppressive, and ignorant. It’s against the spirit of free speech and inquiry. It wants to shut down imagination for the sake of dogma. I do want to remind everyone that well into the 21st century, based on sectarian doctrine, people still try to restrain what the American public can read.

That’s why The American Library Association still has an annual Banned Books Week. It’s why the First Amendment Center has an entire section on the history of book banning in the United States. It’s a shameful history. Harry Potter isn’t the only work that gets challenged. So do books by Langston Hughes, and Kurt Vonnegut, and Chaucer, and Aristophanes.

Holt said he is not calling for a ban on books and feels the responsibility should be on the parents to censor what their children read.

“The word ‘censorship’ is not an ugly word. If you don’t censor what your children see, hear and read, then guess what, your child is going to be spending a lot of time with Pastor Holt later on in life dealing with twisted-up and torn-up lives,” he said.

I absolutely agree that it’s my responsibility as a parent to know about and nurture my kids’ reading. So: hands off the library, Pastor Holt. I don’t want you anywhere near its books, or telling my family what we can and cannot read.

6 responses to “Why yes, this is an attempt to ban books

  1. Your observation, “This wearies me” sums it up very well, I think

  2. He wants to get rid of the “Twilight” series?
    And we’re stopping him… because?


  3. I totally agree. I would have loved to have the writers young adults have these days. It doesn’t matter the story, it’s the writing that counts.

  4. Are you serious? Banning books is of a time past, not now. You have to wonder what sort of brain … never mind. I just think this is ridiculous!

  5. Banning Books, It’s the Witch Burning of the Present!

  6. My Bay Area students LOVE looking through the banned book lists and snorting in disbelief. Most of our high school curriculum and many of their childhood favs are targets.
    I personally found many Old Testament stories too disturbing for bedtime reading with my young kids. My eldest was horrified that God ordered Abraham to kill his child to prove obedience. And Pastor Missick doesn’t understand human nature if he wants to close down fantasy, magic and horror.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s